That's the Herpes talking.
Bruce Campbell Online
RPG World
NINJA!
The Talamasca 2
T-Shirt Hell ... The place your mother warned you about.
Vote for me on the Top 150 Comic sites!
The Bruce Campbell Interview... Groovy! Get Joe in Episode III! Bring The Tick to Video and DVD! Click Here!
Resident DVDvil :: A League of Their Own: Special Edition
[ Rants ]
Sunday, April 18, 2004
 

I have a lot of weird character traits, but one I’ve never been able to explain is the fact that I loathe sports, yet I love sports movies. You couldn’t pay me to waste an afternoon watching a bunch of guys chasing after a ball, whether it is Base, Foot, Basket or Soccer. Yet I have in the past plunked down my own cold hard cash to sit in a theatre to watch “The Natural” (Base), “Semi-Tough” (Foot), “Hoosiers” (Basket), and “Bend it Like Beckham” (Soccer). And even though it is only vaguely about Baseball, I will watch “Field of Dreams” any chance I get.

One of my personal favorites also has to be 1992’s “A League of Their Own,” starring Geena Davis, Lori Petty and Tom Hanks. The film was based around the All-American Girl’s Baseball Team of 1943. Davis starred as Dottie Hinson, who is recruited into the league because she is a babe who happens to swing a bat like Babe Ruth. She insists on bringing her baseball playing sister Kit (Lori Petty) along as a stipulation to signing a contract.

Once in the league, she realizes the owners want nothing more than a bunch of pretty girls playing ball in order to keep the fans coming while the male pros are off at war. However, what she wants is to play real baseball.

The film also stars Tom Hanks as Jimmy Dugan, a washed-up ball player who is hired to ‘coach’ Hinson’s team. The team itself consists of a multitude of clashing personality types, which cause no end of headaches for Dugan. Leading the pack are Madonna (who is for once, not annoying) and Rosie O’Donnell (during the two hours of her career when she was actually funny).

I’ve seen “A League of Their Own” numerous times, and I still love this movie with a passion. Even now, I still find it hard to believe that Penny Marshall (of “Laverne & Shirley”) became such a terrific big league film director. Everything about this film just clicks, from the sisterly relationship of Dottie and Kit, to the underlying attraction that grows between Dottie and Jimmy. The latter is especially poignant as Dottie remains, rightfully so, faithful to her husband (Bill Pullman) who is off fighting in the war.

The film is equal parts funny and sad, with just the right amount of schmaltz to cause a few tears now and then. Even playing the game of baseball is made to look exciting (thanks to the wonder of movie magic). I held off on owning the DVD of the movie for a while and I’m glad I did. Sony / Columbia Tristar is not only releasing an all-new Special Edition, but an all-new Special Edition with TWO discs and a bunch a great extra features.

The first disc is double-sided, giving you the choice between Widescreen and Full Screen (though why you would want to watch it Full Screen, I’ll never understand). It includes a commentary by director Penny Marshall, and actresses Lori Petty (Kit Keller), Tracey Reiner (Betty ‘Spaghetti’ Horn), and Megan Cavanaugh (Marla Hooch). It’s a fairly entertaining commentary, but I think you might find it geared a little more to a female audience’s point of view. .You can listen to the commentary on either version.

The second disc is where you find all the extra trimmings. First you’ll find 15 deleted scenes (about a half hour’s worth) complete with optional introductions by Penny Marshall. I recommend watching the intros just to give you a little better understanding of the scene and why it was cut. There is even a scene audiences really wanted to see, but was cut for reasons I totally understand. I’ll give you a hint, it’s between Geena Davis and Tom Hanks. Then there is a terrific all-new documentary that comes in just under an hour. It’s broken up into 9 parts (innings), but you have the option to play them all. Just about everyone involved with the film is interviewed, with the notable exception of Tom Hanks. I’m kind of curious why he wasn’t involved.

Once you’ve made it through the documentary, you can check out the music video by Madonna for “This Used to be My Playground”, if you’re so inclined. Admittedly I’m not at all a fan of Madonna, so I just kind of cringed through it. Finally, there are three movie previews. One for the original ‘Brian’s Song” with James Caan and Billy Dee Williams, “A League of Their Own”, and “The Natural.”

This is a great DVD release for a favorite movie of mine, but I would like to comment a little on the packaging and marketing. I don’t remember what the original poster art looked like, but this DVD features Geena Davis, Tom Hanks and Madonna on the cover, names and all. I have a slight problem with this being sold as a Madonna movie (like that would be a selling point). The stars of the film were Davis, Petty and Hanks. Madonna was just a bit player. Then I was a bit put off by the back of the DVD which described the movie as such, “…Hanks stars as Jimmy Dugan, a washed up ballplayer whose big league days are over. Hired to coach in the All-American Girls Baseball League of 1943 – while the male pros are at war – Dugan finds himself drawn back into the game by the heart and heroics of his all-girl team…”

Why do I have a problem with this you might ask? Well, as much as I love Tom Hanks and think he’s one of the most talented actors around today… that’s NOT what the movie I about!! Though this does happen in the film, the main focus of the story is on sisters Dottie Hinson and Kit Keller and what happens to their relationship as they become involved with the game. Everyone else’s stories are secondary, Dugan’s included. Again, I think Hanks is a terrific actor, but the movie simply isn’t about him. But I digress.

Aside from this little bit of marketing shenanigans, the new 2-disc Special Edition release of “A League of Their Own” is well worth the bucks to pick up a copy. “PLAY BALL!”

Directed by: Penny Marshall
Starring: Geena Davis, Lori Petty, Tom Hanks, Madonna, Rosie O’Donnell, Jon Lovitz, David Straithairn, Gary Marshall, Bill Pullman
Extras: Director and Cast Commentary, 15 Deleted Scenes with Introductions by Director Penny Marshall, “Nine Memorable Innings” Documentary, Madonna’s “This Used to be My Playground” Music Video
Specifications: Widescreen (2.35:1), Full Screen (1.33:1), English 4.0 Dolby Surround
Studio: Sony / Columbia Tristar
Release Date: 4/20/2004
Region 1
MPAA Rating: PG
Website

We'll give A League of Their Own: Special Edition an A.

[ Back ]
All text, images, and other content © 2002 LethalDeath.com unless otherwise noted.
Questions, comments? Send 'em here.
Get hosted with eHostingBiz