| I've been waiting for this film for something
like four months. Thank god it didn't disappoint.
First, so you know: No Man's Land is a
Bosnian war movie, yes, but much of it does involve
a good deal of comedy, usually relying on the
absurdity of what war really is. If you could
not stand the humor elements of Three Kings,
you should probably stay the hell away from this
one. Though you'll be robbing yourself of a thought-provoking
and extremely well-crafted flick.
No Man's Land takes place at the center
of the Bosnian/Serbian conflict, and if that shies
you away because you know little or nothing about
said conflict (like myself), fear not. All that
you really need to know for the reality of the
film is laid out. Through a series of events too
complicated to explain (and it's a better joy
to watch them unfold anyway), both a Bosnian and
a Serb find themselves stuck in a trench between
both sides' lines, in the titular No Man's Land.
To add to the shenanigans, another Serbian lays
in the trench with them -- perfectly healthy,
but on top of a pressure-sensitive mine. Being
on it is fine, but if he moves himself off...
everyone's dead.
Not too long after, the UN catches wind of this
particularly unique situation, and through the
manipulation of one UN sergeant who protests the
idea of neutrality in such a brutal war, and an
english journalist, decide to get involved. The
UN comes off (not surprisingly) like an All-Star
Team -- soldiers wear the fatigues of their various
countries, matching blue helmets (I've never heard
of UN troops referred to as "Smurfs,"
and damn is it funny), terminally lacking anything
resembling validity. They are troops apparently
assigned to sit around and watch people die.
This interesting premise is the setup for a film
that peers into the psychology of hate-driven
war and the mentality behind peacekeepers who
don't even know the native language of the country
they inhabit. The two soldiers, trapped together,
snipe at each other (sometimes literally) and
exchange little in basic human pleasantries. They
know little of their own motivations, or of which
side is the 'evil' one -- they fight because they're
told, and with the conviction only career soldiers
have. They fight because it's all they have. They
fight because they know no other way to live.
The man on the mine, perhaps close enough to death
to know what really matters, acts as their
voice of reason. When they're all looking death
in the face, why withhold cigarettes from the
other guy, even if he's your sworn enemy?
The movie loses a touch of focus when the peculiar
center of the movie reaches outward; suddenly
a film focused almost claustrophobically on one
trench stretches out to a UN outpost, UN headquarters,
and via the media, London. Watching the chain
of command in action, watching the reporters alternate
between a special kind of freedom fighter and
simple misery vultures -- all necessary to make
their points, but they detract from the fascinating
little microcosm of the three troops stuck in
the trench.
What I really did like about the movie
was that it treaded dangerously close to stepping
into cliché territory, and avoided it.
It would have been easy enough for the movie to
wander into story-swapping territory; the three
soldiers swapping stories about their kids or
wives or whatever, overcoming basic human stubbornness
to act like some kind of We Are the World miniverse.
Easy, too, it would have been to make the media
either all righteous or all evil. The soldiers
are not fast friends, and indeed, they never really
become friends. They are automatons in their cause,
struggling futilely to take a good, solid look
at the world around them.
It's no great stretch to say that war is ugly,
brutal, absurd, and in at times funny, as the
ultimate in gallows humor. Indeed, No Man's
Land would be the ultimate exercise in trite
criticism if it were made by, say, an American
or a Brit, but NML is a Bosnian film, and
this fact alone is enough to fuel the storyline
and the feelings behind them with authenticity
no outsider could ever match. What we end up with
is a searing portrait of the futility of pacifism,
the face of ethnic cleansing, and a glimpse of
ultimate European sophistication. And despite
this sophistication (the queerly heartwarming
sight of an english journalist, french sergeant,
and german mine expert working together being
the most poignant), one thing remains quite clear.
We are an ugly species, us humans, and nothing
we're doing now will change that. |